November 19, 2026: What Is Creativity

Transcript of the Virtual Worlds Education Roundtable: November 19, 2026
Topic: What Is Creativity?
Photos by Sheila Yoshikawa and Beth Ghostraven

How would you define “creativity” and can you give some examples of being creative? Do you feel you are creative in your teaching? Is there something special about being creative in Second Life?

[12:04] Sheila Yoshikawa: Hi everyone, and welcome to the Virtual Worlds Education Roundtable in association with the Virtual Worlds Education Consortium.
[12:04] Sheila Yoshikawa: VWER meets on Thursdays at 12 noon SLT for an hour, in the UK it’s 7pm this week, 3pm EST.
[12:04] Sheila Yoshikawa: VWER is a forum to educate and inform the community about issues that are important and relevant to education in virtual worlds.
[12:04] Sheila Yoshikawa: This is a public meeting, so we will be keeping and publishing a transcript.
[12:05] Sheila Yoshikawa: The transcripts can be found at https://vwer.info/. The VWER continues to develop a community of educators from around the world.
[12:05] Sheila Yoshikawa: Please join the VWER group here in SL.
[12:05] Sheila Yoshikawa: If you are on Facebook please join our group there http://www.facebook.com/groups/159154226946/
[12:05] Sheila Yoshikawa: The topic for this week’s meeting will be: What is creativity?
[12:05] Sheila Yoshikawa: Before that Let’s start as we normally do and introduce ourselves, in text chat.
[12:05] Nellie Homewood: Great topic
[12:06] Beth Ghostraven: I hope Marly can be here soon
[12:06] Beth Ghostraven: Hi Skipper and Nellie!
[12:06] Sheila Yoshikawa: I am in the School of Information Journalism and Communication at the University of Sheffield, UK, and I’m leader of VWER
[12:06] Valibrarian Gregg: Here she is! welcome Marly
[12:06] Skipper Abel: Hi everyone
[12:07] Sheila Yoshikawa: even as Beth spoke, Marly appears
[12:07] Valibrarian Gregg: Valerie Hill – Valibrarian – Library/Information Science educator/researcher, Seattle WA https://linktr.ee/Valibrarian I love the VWER group and the amazing discussions we have here.
[12:07] Skipper Abel: Skipper Abel HE Lecturer in Computing. I run Coders central and Spaceport UK (AKA Aso Galicia) in SL, Azimuth Campus on Kitely and provide introduction to building and Scripting for Avatarlife
[12:07] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): is Lynne Berrett, founder of the nonprofit Ageless Mind Project (https://www.agelessmindproject.org/) and its virtual home: Whole Brain Health on Inspiration Island and Bay in SL. Discover how to build your brain health and promote your total wellbeing through immersive lifelong learning activities ..
[12:07] Dex Euromat: For my sizes, shopping in RL is hard. Most shops in malls do not have more than 2XL EU size, so you have to shop online or go to local… marketplaces
[12:07] Max Chatnoir: Ni, Marly, Nellie
[12:07] Beth Ghostraven: Hi Marly! I was hoping you’d be here for this topic – creativity!
[12:07] Nellie Homewood: Canadian teacher educator, researcher, and educational technology innovator specializing in AI-enhanced learning. She develops Moodle plugins, intelligent AI agents, and immersive learning environments in Second Life and OpenSimulator. Founder of Integrating Technology and AI in Education, she provides accessible professional development and shares innovations through her YouTube channel. Teach immersive experiences at Democritus University of Thrace in Greece at a distance.
[12:07] Beth Ghostraven: I’m a retired teacher-librarian in RL and owner of Ghostraven Professional Attire and GPA Dinkies, modest BOM and flexi clothing for educators in SL (http://bethghostraven.com). I’ve been an unofficial liaison between education groups in SL (AKA Spam Queen) since around 2012. I’ll be taking photos to publish with the transcript (eventually); if you have any objection, please IM me.
[12:07] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): Shi Emmons… Program Director and Events Manager at Scienti sim, with Curious George (Director).
[12:08] Dex Euromat: Dex Euromat (SL) / MEng. Dominik Undak (RL). Co-creator and consultant in Academia Electronica Urban Dream (224,40,22)
Creator and Owner of Poland History House
Website: https://plhisthouseinsl.squarespace.com/ SLURL: Madhupak (202,130,65)
Fireside with Polish at VWEC – Sunday, Noon PT/SLT
Born and living in Poland, Graduated from AGH Science and Technology University, Krakow.
Contact via e-mail dexgaseclife@gmail.com or FB: https://www.facebook.com/dominik.undak
[12:08] Marly (marly.milena): Niela Miller= see The Symbolic Bridge at lulu.com/bookstore. I combine arts, psychology, education in a variety of ways
[12:09] Max Chatnoir: AKA M.A. Clark, Professor Emerita, biology. Builder of Genome Island, a virtual genetics laboratory, where I taught an in world genetics class for 14 years.
[12:10] Sheila Yoshikawa: So, the context for today’s topic is that I am hoping to get a little project going exploring the creativity of older women in virtual worlds. I’ve discussed this with a few people so far but when it’s planned out a bit more I will involve anyone interested 😉
[12:10] Sheila Yoshikawa: Part of this is thinking about what creativity and especially what it means here in a virtual world.
[12:10] Eleanor Medier: Medier Publishing with books and exhibits on topics of art, history, and social issues. My current show is at SLEA Teach Peace Art Fusion Expo called Heroes of War, Heroes of Peace that challenges social conventions. It takes viewers back 1000 years to the origins of the first mass peace movement and shows a reconstruction of the Bayeux Tapestry.
[12:10] Nellie Homewood: Older as in over 40?
[12:10] Sheila Yoshikawa: For this discussion obviously we’re thinking of the creativity of ANYONE (not just older women)
[12:10] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): hah hah, Sheila
[12:10] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Nellie as over 55
[12:11] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): Science and Art have a strong parallel….
[12:11] Nellie Homewood: Just kidding
[12:11] Sheila Yoshikawa: but as I said for today’s VWER don’t restrict it!
[12:11] Sheila Yoshikawa: Think of the creativity of all people who come into a virtual world
[12:11] Eleanor Medier: there are studies that prove we get more creative
[12:11] Sheila Yoshikawa: though you may want to speak from personal experience
[12:12] Dex Euromat: And the creativity. If you happen to live in Poland during Soviet Union era, you know that without it, surviving would be hard 🙂
[12:12] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): are you limiting creativity to artistic creativity?
[12:12] Sheila Yoshikawa: no
[12:12] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): but that begs the issue: why is ART seen As Creative.. but Science, for a long time, was Not seen as Creative
[12:12] Sheila Yoshikawa: well
[12:12] Marly (marly.milena): That book about me (Symbolic Bridge) is all about my creative work life (I am now 91) including a bunch about SL
[12:12] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): yes, Dex…
[12:12] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): will be great to have you share your ideas here, Marly
[12:12] Sheila Yoshikawa: if YOUR idea of creativity is restricted to art – then you could say that, that’s what it means to you
[12:12] Max Chatnoir: Well, we do sort of make it up…. that’s what hypotheses are
[12:13] Valibrarian Gregg: good point @Shiloh- being a librarian is (imho) the most creative job in a school! I got to do creative interactive projects that connect to literature, info, and all subjects in fascinating ways (The art room is not the only place lol)
[12:13] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): creative thinking
[12:13] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): and without the Theatre… Ludwik Solski… Poland struggled to retain its National Identity… when divided between the dominant powers
[12:13] Marly (marly.milena): It might be clearer to talk about Creative Process which could include any focus
[12:13] Stranger Nightfire: I think of creativity as any form of original thinking
[12:13] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Dex that’s an excellent point, also I had a Syrian friend exiled in teh UK, she was helping people in Syria solve problems and they were having to be very creative to survive
[12:14] Sheila Yoshikawa: from growing vegetables, making things, to escaping Syria
[12:14] Sheila Yoshikawa: things
[12:14] Nellie Homewood: I used to think it was only about art because I painted a lot and studied art in high school, but then I got into technology and realized that you can be creative in any area.
[12:14] Elli Pinion: I hadn’t thought of that, Dex. It might be interesting to hear how people were able to be creative during that difficult time.
[12:14] Valibrarian Gregg: Life is a creative process and older people have more experience with it…. but I believe all people can be creative
[12:14] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): related to curiosity?
[12:15] Nellie Homewood: Original and the ability to come up with many ideas, in my opinion.
[12:15] Stranger Nightfire: One of the big debates about AI it’s about whether it can be creative
[12:15] Eleanor Medier: SL allows creativity in a more expansive, inclusive, and multi media potential
[12:15] Eleanor Medier: we can push ideas further
[12:15] Beth Ghostraven: curiosity, and maybe the unwillingness to stick with the status quo?
[12:15] Sheila Yoshikawa: Stranger said “creativity as any form of original thinking” – and that also includes original making?
[12:16] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): if people recognize that they are being creative–when they themselves don’t recognize it–it can have a profoundly positive effect on their sense of self
[12:16] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): Stranger, I do not think AI is necessarily creative on its own. With Human interaction and guidance, AI as a tool becomes creative.
[12:16] Nellie Homewood: Can machines be creative?
[12:16] Eleanor Medier: the willingness to look at an old question from a new viewpoint
[12:16] Sheila Yoshikawa: curiosity, openness ….
[12:17] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): I ask Copilot to be creative for me. Sometimes with specifics, other times I let it gather its own insight and create.
[12:17] Eleanor Medier: making new connections– AI does some of that by patterning
[12:17] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): flexible thinking
[12:17] Nellie Homewood: seeing different perspectives and applying them or not
[12:17] Marly (marly.milena): It is also interesting (as in NOVA series about Evolution) that many creative processes unfold as a result of mutations or “mistakes”
[12:17] Sheila Yoshikawa: and not self-censoring too much?
[12:17] Nellie Homewood: Can thinking be creative or do you need to produce?
[12:17] Valibrarian Gregg: yes! mistakes are so valuable to learning, thinking and creativity
[12:18] Eleanor Medier: if AI comes up with it, maybe that is proof it is NOT an original idea!
[12:18] Marly (marly.milena): Also synchronous happenings
[12:18] Eleanor Medier: i always get ideas from my mistakes
[12:18] Dex Euromat: @Shiloh Not only theatre, but also literature and music. Remember that people during the partitions often were diminished for speaking their language, so they have to invent codes, special phrases that slips through censorship and other clever ways to get through to others.
[12:18] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): on the other hand… when I have been doing research… Copilot assessed another AI program’s output.. and when that program did not give the desired specific results, Copilot adjusted the prompt it had me use.
[12:18] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Nellie interesting I suppose if you don’t produce something noone else knows you’re creative?
[12:19] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): so… creativity might entail some adjustment, adaptation, and evaluation in its process.
[12:19] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): does someone else need to know?
[12:19] Valibrarian Gregg: and does that even matter?
[12:19] Nellie Homewood: @Sheila Yoshikawa Do other people need to know?
[12:19] Valibrarian Gregg: jinx Liss!
[12:19] Max Chatnoir: Good question. Secret creativity?
[12:19] Nellie Homewood: Liss ditto
[12:19] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): private creativity
[12:19] Marly (marly.milena): I am creative every day of my life and, often, others never see it
[12:19] Sheila Yoshikawa: I suppose @Nellie that I think I have had creative thoughts – made up stories and things – that I’ve not shared with anyone
[12:19] Nellie Homewood: Exactly, Marly
[12:20] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): ah.. yes, good point, Dex… Dex points out the use of Native Language in the creative process….
[12:20] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): we often do not recognize our own creativity
[12:20] Skipper Abel: There seems to be good evidence to show that we are at our most creative just before we fall asleep
[12:20] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): nods to Skipper
[12:20] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): and in the shower 🙂
[12:21] Eleanor Medier: and when i wake up
[12:21] Sheila Yoshikawa: possibly related the tales of authors etc having pads by their beds to scribble things that strike them when they are drowsy or just woke up
[12:21] Eleanor Medier: sorry Skipper
[12:21] Nellie Homewood: I read somewhere that people who fly in their sleep are creative.
[12:21] Marly (marly.milena): Also, amazing things happen when more than one person is present and there is a passing of thoughts and ideas back and forth. I was bowled over by what I witnessed at the M.I.T. Media Lab
[12:21] Eleanor Medier: jamming
[12:21] Sheila Yoshikawa: getting into the flow
[12:21] Marly (marly.milena): Yes, like jazz
[12:22] Skipper Abel: Social constructiveness
[12:22] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): think of all the brainstorming sessions we have been in
[12:22] Eleanor Medier: i envy musicians in that sharing of creative output
[12:22] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): theater people too
[12:22] Sheila Yoshikawa: though it could be like focus groups, where one person’s very creative idea might get stifled because it is swamped in the jamming –
[12:22] Marly (marly.milena): Try making up a recipe with a friend in your kitchen! Such fun
[12:22] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): plays are a composite
[12:22] Nellie Homewood: I also envy musicians, Eleanor.
[12:23] Max Chatnoir: Good reason for text!
[12:23] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): chefs… like Dentists… are very creative
[12:23] Eleanor Medier: confidence has to go with creativity– you have to believe when an idea hits the mark
[12:23] Nellie Homewood: Dentists???
[12:23] Marly (marly.milena): Playing, fooling around, so important. Kids do it naturally and adults often have to relearn it
[12:23] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): correct Nellie
[12:23] Sheila Yoshikawa: speaking as the wife of someone who was an actor – it seemed like unfortunately a lot of theatre was more about negotiating egos lol
[12:23] Nellie Homewood: being playful is creative in my opinion
[12:23] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): Dentists are recreating facial appearance
[12:23] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): I know many dentists who are sculptors actually
[12:23] Dex Euromat: We have this word “kombinować” which can be translated to few phrases, but for this topic the best would be: to combine things creatively to get something done.
[12:24] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): that, too, Sheila… sadly
[12:24] Sheila Yoshikawa: nice word @Dex!
[12:24] Nellie Homewood: Nice, Dex
[12:24] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): oh nice dex!
[12:24] Eleanor Medier: the creative solution is the most elegant– and efficient
[12:25] Max Chatnoir: practical!
[12:25] Sheila Yoshikawa: So far we have mentioned librarians, scientists, people suffering oppression, dentists, theatre people, nice variety of creativities
[12:25] Marly (marly.milena): So, Sheila, any specific questions for us?
[12:25] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): awareness of one’s creativity seems to be important–helps to nurture it
[12:25] Valibrarian Gregg: I have an Indigo blue pot that looks like Aladdin’s lamp with tons of little thought provoking notes of meaning. I have jotted them down for years. Someday when I slow down I shall ponder them all. My secret poetic stash 😉
[12:25] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): chefs too
[12:25] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): chefs are very very creative
[12:26] Nellie Homewood: and dentists?
[12:26] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): the process of cooking is creative.. the display of food is creative
[12:26] Nellie Homewood: so it’s a process
[12:26] Sheila Yoshikawa: well, the first question was what people thought creativity was, and there has been an excellent range of ideas and examples
[12:26] Marly (marly.milena): You can have a creative mind and spirit without a vocational designation!
[12:26] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): both
[12:26] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): both process and finished product
[12:26] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): is anyone creative in the way they clean house? that’s a really valuable use of creativity
[12:26] Beth Ghostraven: I think Val and I mean school librarians (teacher-librarians) in particular
[12:26] Nellie Homewood: isn’t everyone creative
[12:26] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): hahahahah, Lissi
[12:27] Beth Ghostraven: LIss, I’m creative in the ways I avoid cleaning house
[12:27] Stranger Nightfire: I would say as in most things it depends Some shafts are creat and some chefs are walking recipe books
[12:27] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): that takes thought!
[12:27] Eleanor Medier: Isn’t creativity more than solutions to problems?
[12:27] Nellie Homewood: being mindful as you clean the house or do the dishes
[12:27] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Marly yes, but I found it interesting to think about vocations that weren’t normally thought of as primarily creative
[12:27] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): they way the knick knacks are displayed !!
[12:27] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): good question Eleanor
[12:27] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Eleanor yes, I would say you can be creative without having to be “useful”
[12:28] Nellie Homewood: You can play around and create things with soap as you do the dishes
[12:28] Valibrarian Gregg: Genius- comes from “to beget” or give birth Genesis- the beginning … all children are like geniuses until the art teacher says “you have done it wrong”!
[12:28] Sheila Yoshikawa: I have tended to think of creativity being unfettered by usefulness
[12:28] Valibrarian Gregg: or some other adult says that
[12:28] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): many people speak of creativity with a small or large C
[12:28] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): creativity can be a need to express oneself… via music, food, art, language (poetry), dance or just thinking outside the box
[12:28] Eleanor Medier: i agree Sheila– to me it is putting things together that never were together before and say something new
[12:28] Nellie Homewood: Has anyone taken a creativity test?
[12:28] Marly (marly.milena): I think it is a mistake to align creativity with professions and to look at it as a way of life, a process regardless of the content or any particular result
[12:28] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): well
[12:28] Marly (marly.milena): It can be applied in any way
[12:28] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): that begs another question
[12:28] Dex Euromat: And paradoxically things that were winged up (improvised) are the ones that works the longest. Looks stupid but works – then it’s not stupid 🙂
[12:29] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): 🙂
[12:29] Max Chatnoir: I heard somewhere that young children ask about 100 questions an hour.
[12:29] Beth Ghostraven: Max, that might be a conservative estimate
[12:29] Stranger Nightfire: What was said about dish soap made me think of the amazing scene and close encounters about mashed potatoes
[12:29] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): when AI does create art.. and it is not perfect… we tell it : AI you are wrong… Should we be doing that ????
[12:29] Sheila Yoshikawa: lol @Beth Ghostraven
[12:29] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): mashed potatoes?
[12:29] Dex Euromat: @Max Chatnoir 100, I heard some can ask 1000 😛
[12:29] Marly (marly.milena): AI creates images,not art IMO
[12:29] Stranger Nightfire: The character was creating a sculpture with the mashed potatoes on his plate
[12:29] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): exactly , Marly… Georgia O’Keeffe used to collect pebbles / stones
[12:30] Eleanor Medier: i have a friend that just did a series on bubbles in his sink
[12:30] Max Chatnoir: a sculpting medium?
[12:30] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): and display them on the window sill
[12:30] Nellie Homewood: oh yes, mash potatoes and bread; I used to make things with bread as kid and then eat it
[12:30] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Marly so for you it is part of your way of being?
[12:30] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): I have to agree with what Marly points out
[12:30] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Eleanor that sounds fun!
[12:30] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): is daydreaming a form of creativity?
[12:30] Eleanor Medier: they were great
[12:30] Elli Pinion: I also agree with Marly
[12:30] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): yes, Stranger
[12:31] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): I think it is, Lissi.
[12:31] Sheila Yoshikawa: yes re AI when I use AI to create images it IS for a specific purpose, it isn’t to be creative really
[12:31] Marly (marly.milena): Yes, Sheila, I call myself a Creativist. I move around from one medium or project or conversation to another. It’s the process that’s important. The medium can be anything
[12:31] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): I do think creativity pushes one to MAKE something
[12:31] Dex Euromat: by all means yes, Liss.
[12:31] Nellie Homewood: Again, the creative process
[12:32] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): yes, Sheila.. but I do let Copilot… create ideas on its own
[12:32] Eleanor Medier: we talk more about AI these days– but SL is as influential
[12:32] Nellie Homewood: If we stop and focus on the process, we can gain a lot pleasure
[12:32] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): how Eleanor?
[12:33] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): so… although Copilot gathers patterns from all the information it knows, Copilot configures the drawing based on the LLM inspiration.
[12:33] Eleanor Medier: potential Liss– the way we can do things here that we cant afford to do or it is impossible to do in RL
[12:33] Nellie Homewood: Is asking AI to generate art being creative?
[12:33] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): important point
[12:33] Eleanor Medier: I do multimedia projects here, and am more restricted in R:
[12:33] Marly (marly.milena): See the video of my session called Preserving the Ability to Create from Scratch [https://youtu.be/vIgDslU1YLs]
[12:33] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): yes and that’s the reason I came into SL–to do things it would be hard to do in RL
[12:34] Sheila Yoshikawa: So – SECOND QUESTION – Is there something special about being creative in Second Life?
[12:34] Dex Euromat: Variety of forms, look around. Without creativity, there will be only bunch of data clouds sitting here just on the ground, or maybe underwater.
[12:34] Eleanor Medier: I agree with Shiloh– AI is a tool. It is how we manage it, instruct it, and choose from what it does
[12:34] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): i stand on the position, Nellie, that AI is creative.
[12:34] Sheila Yoshikawa: Is there something special about being creative in Second Life?
[12:34] Nellie Homewood: Some people think that AI generated images and videos is an art form
[12:34] Nellie Homewood: Creativity is in the eyes of the creator.
[12:34] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): our ideas about AI and art will likely evolve over time
[12:34] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): but… Eleanor, I go further, I say: Vector, you be creative, interpret what you find .. and generate an art image.
[12:34] Sheila Yoshikawa: lol just trying to wrest us away from AI for a little while
[12:34] Eleanor Medier: yes Sheila there is something very special about being creative here
[12:35] Elli Pinion: I believe there is, Sheila.
[12:35] Eleanor Medier: AI is creative in the sense that it patterns from what has been done
[12:35] Sheila Yoshikawa: I would say SL has sparked my creativity, because of its visual nature
[12:35] Nellie Homewood: Math can also be very creative
[12:35] Marly (marly.milena): There are AI folks now working on the ability of AI to be creative beyond what it has been fed. Kinda scary
[12:35] Elli Pinion: Since the world is built by the users.
[12:35] Nellie Homewood: I agree that SL can make people creative
[12:35] Eleanor Medier: AI still needs references though
[12:36] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Elli I do feel inspired by the creations – that are all around us here
[12:36] Eleanor Medier: SL makes art more accessible
[12:36] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): yes, but Nellie, how is what AI produces… any different than.. what an Illustrator produced for a book??? As a matter of fact, Illustration was not often seen as so-called creativity… it was not viewed as the same thing as Fine Art… or artistic expression.
[12:36] Elli Pinion: Me, too. It inspires us to also create.
[12:37] Sheila Yoshikawa: I mean in the physical world as I sit I am surrounded by many “created” items, but some are mass produced, but also we have a lot of individual items
[12:37] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): yes, I agree, Sheila.. we are sitting in an art setting
[12:37] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): last night Dancoyote, who creates the Skydances, came to a far-out music event at WBH and was like a constantly evolving butterfly above us all–gorgeous!
[12:37] Eleanor Medier: AI can improve ideas and make visual what a person would take days to do
[12:37] Nellie Homewood: I’ve created many Moodle plugins and AI Agents, but that’s not being creative as far as I’m concerned. I’m my ideas are creative and process is, but the outcome is not.
[12:37] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): but.. in real life… we plant flowers, grow trees… landscape.. we also live in a art setting
[12:38] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): Landscapers were a noble class of people back in the day
[12:38] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): Is the outcome something new, Nellie?
[12:38] Elli Pinion: Good point, Liss. Even our avatars can be part of us being creative.
[12:38] Nellie Homewood: yes, it’s new Liss very new
[12:38] Eleanor Medier: i can incorporate other media into my ideas in SL that I cant in RL
[12:38] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): that is a form of creativity as far as I am concerned
[12:39] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): @Nellie Homewood
[12:39] Eleanor Medier: I think avatars are self portraits
[12:39] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): there is nothing wrong with being inspired by book knowledge
[12:39] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): is inspiration needed for creativity?
[12:39] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Shiloh interesting, when wandering a park I respond to it more as – nature – rather than something created – even if it is beautifully landscaped
[12:39] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): even non fiction writing… it is a creative process…
[12:39] Nellie Homewood: I feel my imagination alive in SL and in OpenSim, maybe more in OS.
[12:39] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): yes, Sheila
[12:39] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): the role of imagination in this can be explored too
[12:40] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): in UK it was a noble profession
[12:40] Eleanor Medier: Nellie– isn’t that because there are more possibilities?
[12:40] Nellie Homewood: Possibilities, yes, Eleanor and
[12:40] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): well, Eleanor.. it makes you more critical of museum exhibits these days… !!!!
[12:40] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): you have to make so much yourself in opensim
[12:41] Nellie Homewood: exactly, Liss – that’s why I love it
[12:41] Nellie Homewood: I need to build.
[12:41] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): do you feel other people’s creativity inspires you more in SL?
[12:41] Sheila Yoshikawa: I think for me, being in the virtual world seems to give me permission to be freer and more open, or see more options?
[12:41] Eleanor Medier: Actually, I didn’t consider creating a museum– and so to grow this way is something transformational
[12:41] Marly (marly.milena): Although I admire and enjoy all the wonderful visual creations here, my main interest is how we can use the tools here to be engaged in creative processes that support self-understanding, problem solving, decision making, etc, not products as end results
[12:41] Dex Euromat: Creativity is one thing, but it cannot work without imagination. AI is only predicting the best scenario, It can produce many copies of same thing. Human can too, but each time it will be slightly different, even if all things around would be the same. Because people can change their process any moment. AI has one process of evaluation the input and output, it not change this process.
[12:41] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): or in virtual worlds maybe I should say
[12:42] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): good point Dex
[12:42] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): @Lissi… sometimes. Sometimes.. music alone inspires.. a feeling.. Or.. a setting either in real life or in virtual life… can inspire
[12:42] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): in virtual rather than just in SL
[12:42] Nellie Homewood: Dex, I think being aware of the process has many benefits.
[12:42] Eleanor Medier: Marly– SL allows more of that sharing process and interactive feedback– more effect than just the product
[12:42] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): very true, Dex
[12:43] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): it is not like AI suddenly goes and does something without a prompt… at least not yet… (not that we know of, anyway)
[12:43] Nellie Homewood: Ha ha Shiloh
[12:43] Sheila Yoshikawa: interesting @Marly, I suppose I am at least as interested in teh end results, I can think of numerous times I have just stood in SL and wondered at the glory and imagination of what has been created (and sometimes not stood, sometimes being whisked round in an art work)
[12:43] Valibrarian Gregg: As a writing trainer (helping teachers get kids to write)- I read that most people view the world through a particular literary genre! Poetry, history (facts), news reporter (current events), fiction (imagination) etc. My lens is poetry but I found when I became a researcher…. there is poetry there, too. It is everywhere if you see it that way. Interesting how we perceive the world.
[12:43] Nellie Homewood: Yes, imagine one day, we will think it, and AI will do it
[12:43] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): yes Val
[12:44] Valibrarian Gregg: I saw SL as a “entering a metaphor” which is like entering a poem.
[12:44] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): beautiful, Val
[12:44] Valibrarian Gregg: @Nellie Homewood I do not want to live in a world where I think and AI does it
[12:44] Nellie Homewood: I view the world via images. I see them when people talk or write.
[12:44] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): Val.. that reminds me of two approaches: one is giving a Key word to students.. to work with. The other, as my mother used to do, she would scribble on the backside of a paper place setting and we were then challenged to create something from the scribble.
[12:45] Nellie Homewood: I agree, Val.
[12:45] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): my mother was a great teacher that way, in visual art…
[12:45] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): I can see that, Shi
[12:45] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Val whereas I thought – oooo this is an interesting new place to be! I want more of it! perhaps I see it as autoethnography, even though I didn’t know that word 19 years ago lol
[12:45] Eleanor Medier: Dex– I cant imagine AI will make the leaps of variations and advancement faster or better than the human imagination
[12:45] Valibrarian Gregg: yes @Shiloh I did that a lot in the library… give a word – give a theme… such great critical thinking and creativity stems from it (They brought journals with them for drawing and responding)
[12:45] Max Chatnoir: My mixollamas on Genome started out as hippos…
[12:46] Dex Euromat: Also as human beings we learn things during the life, we have experiences, feelings about those. AI have limited capacity of such things. Even Claude code, has a ‘context’ of maximum 1 Megabyte memory allocation for a project.
[12:46] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): HIPPOS ???!!!!
[12:46] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): Gnome is a great example
[12:46] Sheila Yoshikawa: from hippo to mixollama!
[12:46] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): that is cool…
[12:46] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): Genome even 🙂
[12:46] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): similar to Actors, Dex…
[12:46] Sheila Yoshikawa: BTW Dex what you said about imagination ages ago – agree
[12:48] Marly (marly.milena): We are all actors, switch personas all the time depending on who we are with, what the event is, etc
[12:48] Eleanor Medier: is SL a metaphor in its mirroring of RL?
[12:48] Sheila Yoshikawa remembers the scent of a proper old fashioned red rose – sadly most shop bought ones don’t have that
[12:49] Marly (marly.milena): In effect, we are “creating” who we are to fit with the situation
[12:49] Nellie Homewood: I love and need roses so I have them in my garden.
[12:49] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Marly I agree
[12:49] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): fit the situation?
[12:49] Eleanor Medier: create the situation?
[12:49] Valibrarian Gregg: more than that Eleanor… SL is not just a mirror but a place to build abstract ideas (like my 3D metaliteracy build) so you can think critically and understand them
[12:49] Sheila Yoshikawa: also a FINAL question I had was – Do you feel you are creative in your teaching? (if you teach)
[12:50] Dex Euromat: The Palace of Thoughts – something that only human mind can be trained. I think even with the whole world databases, all knowledge of humanity, AI would not be able to do a fraction of it, It cannot be Sherlock 😛
[12:50] Marly (marly.milena): Yes, who I am sitting here at VWER is not the same as who I am goofing around in my kitchen or with children or at a formal occasion
[12:50] Eleanor Medier: Valibrarian– I agree because SL extends potential and possibilities– creative can be more expansive
[12:50] Valibrarian Gregg: I care more about bringing out the creativity in my students. My own creativity is a secret.
[12:51] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): hmmmm
[12:51] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): immersion and interaction here fosters creativity in the way we teach
[12:51] Marly (marly.milena) whispers: I like looking at (and encouraging others to look at) what the
[12:51] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): I am kind of an extension pretty much of who I am in my physical life..
[12:51] Sheila Yoshikawa: I would say fit the situation – e.g. there are certain clothes I do and do not wear when I’m teaching, and certainly filter what I say
[12:51] Nellie Homewood: I am very creative in the tasks I create for my students.
[12:51] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): that is correct
[12:52] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): but.. then again, I would not wear them in my physical life either
[12:52] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): it’s hard NOT to teach creatively in SL
[12:52] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): I am even MORE modest in real life
[12:52] Marly (marly.milena): fingerprint of my creativity is. When I am making up an educational exercise, a recipe, a piece of music or an art work, there are strands that are complementary
[12:52] Eleanor Medier: I teach through publishing– visual and words– SL helps me to explore themes and push ideas further– and to clarify, and collaborate differently
[12:52] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): why teach here otherwise?
[12:52] Nellie Homewood: I am modest in what I wear in SL and in RL
[12:53] Nellie Homewood: but I am more open in RL than in SL
[12:53] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Liss I think I have seen teaching in SL that is not creative ;-(( though such people don’t usually hang around long
[12:53] Beth Ghostraven: 7 minutes left
[12:53] Eleanor Medier: All of my projects bridge RL and SL– taking advantage of the various capabilities
[12:53] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): when WBH started working with the international students we took them from slide shows to 3D builds
[12:54] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Marly meaning that what you make is complex, with more than one strand!
[12:54] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): but both formats are creative, Lissi
[12:54] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): say more Shiloh?
[12:54] Elli Pinion: Good point, you can be a ‘traditional’ teacher here, as well. But also agree, they don’t last long. What benefit is there?
[12:54] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): it is hard to make an interesting slide show.. and even more demanding to create a Legacy exhibit
[12:54] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Shiloh @Nellie yes, I don’t wear huge ballgowns or full kimono in the physical world, but there is a definite link in what I wear and actually I see how I dress as part of creativity
[12:54] Eleanor Medier: i create what teachers often use– so it is a continuum
[12:54] Marly (marly.milena): Meaning that I have certain ways of approaching any creative task that echo each other no matter WHAT i am working on or thinking about
[12:54] Nellie Homewood: Can you tell someone that they are not creative when they think they are?
[12:55] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): LOL Nellie
[12:55] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): sometimes, yes, Nelli
[12:55] Eleanor Medier: Yes you can
[12:55] Marly (marly.milena): It is useful to try to track HOW you are creative
[12:55] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): but.. like you said.. creativity.. like art.. is in the eye of the beholder.
[12:55] Nellie Homewood: Has anyone ever done that?
[12:55] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): I won’t rain on their parade
[12:55] Eleanor Medier: yes I had to professionally
[12:55] Eleanor Medier: guide ppl to find a better path
[12:56] Nellie Homewood: nice, Eleanor
[12:56] Marly (marly.milena): NOt the medium but the process
[12:56] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): some people are “tone” deaf
[12:56] Nellie Homewood: I agree about the process, Marly
[12:56] Sheila Yoshikawa: I don’t think I have Nellie! ALTHOUGH perhaps in feedback I have given on dissdertations etc., it will sometimes have been saying it wasn’t creative/original enough
[12:56] Valibrarian Gregg: people have different gifts and they can surprise us
[12:56] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): but.. so long as they keep trying and work at their creativity… then they are creative !!
[12:56] Sheila Yoshikawa: dissertations
[12:56] Marly (marly.milena): Sheila, did this discussion help you think about your project?
[12:57] Eleanor Medier: but I have also been wrong
[12:57] Nellie Homewood: Do you think all humans are creative?
[12:57] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Marly yes – to your last question and to the previous statement
[12:57] Sheila Yoshikawa: @Nellie potentially – some in ways that is not desirable in society, or they have creativity crushed out of them
[12:58] Nellie Homewood: Oops @Sheila Yoshikawa yes, negative creativity
[12:59] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): right, Sheila.. as I said: some people are “tone deaf” but.. they should always try to create !!!
[12:59] Marly (marly.milena): One thing we didn’t get to address today which I would find fascinating is creativity in relating
[12:59] Sheila Yoshikawa: Thanks everyone for this creative discussion!
[12:59] Nellie Homewood: Thank you
[12:59] Marly (marly.milena): ie good partnerships and collaborations!
[12:59] Sheila Yoshikawa: Yes, creativity is a generative topic!
[12:59] Marly (marly.milena): \ OK, another day…
[12:59] Marly (marly.milena): LOL
[12:59] Eleanor Medier: thanks so much– with endless things to say 🙂
[13:00] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): Great session today
[13:00] Skipper Abel: Great topic, thank you Sheila and everyone, bye for now and have a good week, Skipper:)
[13:00] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): Thank you, Sheila
[13:00] Nellie Homewood: I can see lasting relationships as involving creativity, Marly
[13:00] Shiloh e. (shiloh.emmons): and.. Happy Thanksgiving everyone..
[13:00] Elli Pinion: Hope everyone in the US has a wonderful Thanksgiving.
[13:00] Nellie Homewood: Canada has its Thanksgiving
[13:00] Sheila Yoshikawa: Oh, yes, no VWER next week
[13:00] Eleanor Medier: Happy Thanksgiving to all! And a great day.
[13:00] Valibrarian Gregg: See you all next time. Happy Thanksgiving and hope to see you at the NPC Community Harvest tomorrow at 8:30am slt
[13:00] Valibrarian Gregg: bye for now
[13:00] Sheila Yoshikawa: Bye!
[13:00] Liss Wisdomseeker (lissena): provocative discussion in the best sense
[13:01] Nellie Homewood: So Happy Thanksgiving to you all
[13:01] Elli Pinion: Great to see everyone.
[13:01] Max Chatnoir: Happy Thanksgiving everybody.
[13:01] Dex Euromat: Gotta go. Bye
[13:01] Dex Euromat: Happy Thanksgiving

VWER Meeting Transcripts by Virtual Worlds Education Roundtable are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. Based on a work at http://vwer.info.

Leave a Reply